Criticism That Builds
Many critics today only want to tear down other’s ideas. This makes sense as it is quite easy to destroy something. It’s building something that takes real work and creativity.
The best criticism will always present an alternative to an opposing idea, and chart a way forward. Since I offered a critique of criticism in my last post (read it here) I ought to practice what I preach and also propose some possible ways to better criticize.
First, give an honest evaluation of all the information. Listen to whole speech or sermon, read the entire book, or research the legislation. Do the hard work; this way, when you do speak, you are informed. We cannot let the opinions of others serve as our sole means of being informed. Learning yourself will allow you to learn more about the issue at hand, and can strengthen your understanding of the argument.
Second, present your argument fairly and allow the listener the opportunity to decide if he agrees with you. If a critic believes herself to be 100% right about something, then all that is needed is for her to present the argument in a clear and compelling way. The closer one can stay to the argument, the more people are invited to listen. Once insults, slander, and accusation begin to enter the picture people are instantly alienated and begin to choose sides. We don’t need the character assassinations - after all, the truth is what will win out in the end, right?
Third, do not offer a criticism until you are willing to accept criticism. Some of the harshest critics are those who hate being criticized. When we are willing listen to our critics we open ourselves to growth. Through them that we can see our blind spots and gain a clearer picture of the issue at hand. Good critics act like a mirror for our thinking, and when they hold it up it will do us good to take a long hard look. The best thinkers I know are those who listen to their critics and learn from them.
None of these ideas can happen, however, unless criticism is rooted in a humble heart. It is the humble that can offer a critique knowing all the while, it’s just an opinion of one person. In the end, their opinion could be wrong. The truth is, all of us are wrong about something - admitting this just may be the first step to becoming a better critic.
What are some ways you would improve criticism? Share your ideas. Together, we will be better and build something that lasts.